Health NZ has been found in breach of care standards after a missed heart attack led to the death of Michelle Pillay, a 47-year-old South African-born woman from Durban. Pillay arrived at Tauranga Hospital in New Zealand by ambulance on 27 September 2022 with severe chest pain, vomiting, and urinary incontinence.
The Health and Disability Commissioner (HDC) released a decision on 9 November 2026 confirming that staff at Tauranga Hospital failed to properly recognise Pillay’s acute cardiac event. Despite abnormal ECG readings at 8:46pm and 9:34pm on the day of her admission, urgent action was not taken.
Deputy Health and Disability Commissioner stated, “I find Health NZ in breach of Right 4(1) of the Code … for failing to provide services to Ms B with reasonable care and skill in relation to the delayed recognition that Ms B was experiencing an acute cardiac event.” The report emphasised that the second and third ECG results were abnormal and “should have prompted immediate action.”
Pillay left Tauranga Hospital shortly after midnight on 28 September with her partner after hours of waiting for care. She was admitted to another hospital later that morning, where she suffered a cardiac arrest and died at 9:07am. The cause of death was confirmed as a heart attack.
The HDC recommended that Health NZ apologise formally to Pillay’s family and make improvements to its ECG processes to avoid similar incidents in the future. RNZ and NZ Herald independently corroborated the findings and confirmed the apology order.
Michelle Pillay’s background as Durban-born was reported by IOL and The Post, highlighting the international implications of the case and the importance of healthcare accountability across borders.
This case draws attention to delays in cardiac care, a critical issue globally and in South Africa, where heart disease remains a significant health concern. The failure to interpret ECG results in time prevented life-saving treatment for Pillay.
Health NZ’s response and details on specific changes made to emergency protocols following the HDC ruling have not been fully disclosed. Further information is awaited on how these systemic improvements will be implemented.
CapeFlats.co.za will monitor developments in this case, with particular focus on how health systems can learn to better identify life-threatening cardiac events and prevent avoidable deaths. The next update is expected following Health NZ’s full implementation report to the HDC.